World federalist movement, civil society meeting on the responsibility to protect, final report, geneva, 28 march 2003, p. An examination of the international communitys response to the crisis in darfur between 2004 and 2007 reveals two contradictory developments regarding the responsibilities of sovereign statehood. The evolving concept and institution of sovereignty challenges and opportunities. Several african states have initiated farreaching reforms that offer hope of. The doctrine of responsibility to protect, as initially set out in the report of the international commission on intervention and state sovereignty of 2001, is difficult to place within the usual framework of ir theories liberal internationalist, realist or radical or international political theories communitarian, cosmopolitan.
Maritime boundaries delimitation and dispute resolution in. The responsibility to protect as a duty of care in. Click download or read online button to africa conflict resolution and international diplomacy book pdf for free now. As united nations secretarygeneral ban kimoon observed in 2008, r2p is built on the positive and affirmative concept of sovereignty as responsibilitya concept developed by. Regional approaches to conflict management in africa during the august 2001 colombian presidency of the council. The recent development of the idea that sovereignty entails a responsibility to protect represents an attempt to enforce the protection of these individual rights. The essay further considers the responsibilities of national democratic governments in africa and beyond. The concept of sovereignty as responsibility was developed at the brookings institution, beginning in 1989 as part of the africa project to investigate conflict management in africa. Conflict management tends to focus more on mitig ating or. This article examines the conflict management potential of. The role of the african union in continental peace and security governance. Pdf african union and conflict resolution in africa.
The paper concludes with a set of recommendations on how regional organizations in africa and ecowas in. One is establishing and applying an effective system of conflict prevention, management, and resolution nationally, regionally, and globally. Conflict management in africa, brookings institution press, 1996. Maritime boundaries delimitation and dispute resolution in africa theodore okonkwo department of public law, faculty of law, university of port harcourt, portharcourt, nigeria abstract africas borders are bestride with many challenges ranging from religious and terrorist movements to cattle rustling, military conflicts to human trafficking. Broad principles are developed by examining identity as a potential source of conflict, governance as a matter of managing conflict, and economics as a policy field for deterring conflict.
In the new world order, should the community of nations continue to adhere to the old principle of nonintervention in the internal affairs of sovereign states so. Broad principles are developed by examining identity as a potential source of conflict, governance as a matter of managing conflict. Conflict management in africa, argues that when nations do not conduct their internal affairs in ways that meet internationally recognized standards, other nations not only have the right, but also have a duty, to intervene. Sovereignty as responsibility, responsibility to protect and. Sovereignty, according to the authors, can no longer be seen as a protection against interference, but as a charge of responsibility where the state is accountable to both domestic and external constituencies.
Sovereignty as responsibility in east asias response to. Sovereignty as responsibility is an international norm that has been cultivated since the end of the cold war, and this book carried the concept from an abstract desire for the future into the realm of serious academic and policy discussion. It then examines the responsibility of states towards their own citizens and traces the development of the r2p norm in africa as it has related to conflict prevention, management, and resolution since the end of the cold war. Governments that have endorsed the sovereignty as responsibility approach have shown little inclination to protect civilians suffering at the hands of their own government in the sudanese province of.
Regional approaches to conflict management in africa. In internal conflicts in africa, sovereign states have often failed to take responsibility for their own citizens welfare and for the humanitarian consequences of conflict, leaving. The challenges posed by internal conflicts have two aspects. Sovereignty as responsibility to the responsibility to protect brill. Relations with donors are highly variable and aid has time and again proven to be a limited tool with which to influence internal change in africa.
Africa conflict resolution and international diplomacy download africa conflict resolution and international diplomacy ebook pdf or read online books in pdf, epub, and mobi format. Pdf the role of the african union in continental peace. For broader discussions of the diverse intellectual traditions that added to this foundation, see s. The lessons from the mixed successes of regional conflict management actions, such as the west african intervention in liberia, the east african mediation in sudan, and international efforts to urge talks to end the conflict in angola, indicate friends and neighbors outside the state in conflict have important roles to play in increasing. This was a fantastic read, and prescient in its focus. Sovereignty as responsibility presents a framework that should guide both national governments and the international community in discharging their respective responsibilities. With regard to conflict, the aprm has stated as one of its objectives the prevention and reduction of inter and intrastate conflict.
Deng, sadikill kimaro, terrence lyons, donald rothchild, and i. Conflict management in africa brookings, 1996, author of racial bargaining in independent kenya oxford university press, 1973, and coeditor of the international spread of ethnic conflict. The antecedents of sovereignty as responsibility luke glanville. In internal conflicts in africa, sovereign states have often failed to take responsibility for their own citizens welfare and for the humanitarian. Responsibility to protect and the problem of military. The antipolitical theory of responsibility to protect in. The superpower competition for global influence exacerbated and. United nations general assembly 60th session, resolution adopted by the general assembly 601. Deng, who is credited with coining the concept of sovereignty as responsibility, holds that in order to avoid being stripped of its sovereignty a state must maintain good governance and provide for the general welfare of its citizens and those under its jurisdiction.
Redefining sovereignty and intervention volume 17 issue 1 joelle tanguy. Haass president, council on foreign relations penguin press. It proposes standards that guide performance and sharpen tools of conflict prevention rather than simply making posthoc judgments on success or failure. Thomas weiss has subsequently reiterated the connections between the libyan intervention and the rtop, but at the time of writing, it remains to be seen if libya will ultimately be understood as a successful application of the rtop doctrine.
The role of the economic community of west african states. Deng, sadikiel kamaro, terrence lyons, donald rothchild, and i. The authors assert that sovereignty can no longer be seen as a protection against interference, but as a charge of responsibility where the state is accountable to both domestic and external constituencies. The evolving concept and institution of sovereignty. Conflict management in africa brookings, 1996, author of racial bargaining in independent kenya oxford university press, 1973, and coeditor. Border security, migration governance and sovereignty.
On a failed canadian attempt to secure a technical general assembly resolution on r2p in 2002, see maria banda, the responsibility to protect. Conflict management in africa ebook written by francis m. The political origins of the responsibility to protect are in africa. The notion of sovereignty as responsibility recognises that sovereignty carries with it responsibilities for the population deng et al 1996. The concept of sovereignty as responsibility is without question one of the foundations for the concept of the responsibility to protect r2p.
To help nudge international opinion closer to an acceptance of sovereignty as conditional, this study, drawing examples from africa, lucidly sets out a framework of concepts and arguments to show how states can prevent, manage, and resolve conflicts that threaten their legitimacy, as well as how international and regional organizations can work to promote norms of responsibility within and among states. International commission on intervention, state sovereignty, and international development research centre canada, the responsibility to protect. International context of conflict management in africa during the bipolar era, the cold war competition and rivalries between two ideological blocs largely shaped the security environment of africa states. Interdisciplinary and intended for nonspecialists, this book provides a new framework for thinking about foreign political and military intervention in africa.
Many challenges facing the african continent today are rooted in colonial practices, cold war alliances, and outsiders attempts to influence its political and economic systems. Sovereignty, according to the authors, can no longer be seen as a protection against interference, but as a charge of responsibility where the state is accountable to both domestic and external. On the one hand, it internationalized otherwise local conflicts. It proposes standards that guide performance and sharpen tools of conflict prevention rather than simply making post hoc judgments on success or failure. Approaching conflict management from the perspective of the responsibilities of sovereignty provides a framework for evaluating government accountability. Broad principles are developed by examining identity as a potential source of conflict, governance as a matter of managing conflict, and economics as a policy field for. Iciss international commission on intervention and state sovereignty lma linas marcoussis accords. Conceptual framework of sovereignty as responsibility. Central in the responsibility to protect r2p framework is a recharacterization of sovereignty from sovereignty as control to sovereignty as responsibility in both internal functions and external duties of states. Responsibility to protect, in late 2001, reconceptualised sovereignty as follows.
The project was led by francis deng, a former sudanese diplomat, who was assisted by roberta cohen, a senior fellow at brookings. American foreign policy and the crisis of the old order by richard n. The responsibility to protect and the crisis in darfur. Against this background, a new idea of sovereignty as responsibility gained attention, stressing the obligation for citizens protection that is implied by state sovereignty 2 francis m. The first application of the military force element of responsibility to protect r2p, whose objective is to protect populations from four specified atrocities, occurred in 2011 in libya. In the new world order, should the community of nations continue to adhere to the old principle of nonintervention in the internal affairs of sovereign states so long as their domestic policies do not constitute a threat to international peace. Notions of sovereignty as responsibility and the responsibility to. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read sovereignty as responsibility. The evolving international law obligations and the sethusamuduram ship channel project chinthaka mendis united nations nippon foundation.
Toole, center for disease control, department of health and human services testimon, y before the us senate, 3 april, 1990, as quoted in refugee policy group, internally displaced women and children in africa. Based on a qualitative analysis of conflict in africa, this paper has identified broad types of conflict in order to understand better the conflict dynamics, causes and drivers on the continent. Conflict management in africa, brookings institution press, 1996 this idea inspired the. Intervention, sovereignty and the responsibility to. Dec 01, 2010 he is the coauthor of sovereignty as responsibility. Border security, migration governance and sovereignty susan martin and elizabeth ferris a time of paradoxes we live in an increasingly borderless world where funds can be transferred across borders with a swipe on a smartphone, where automobiles and computers are made up of parts produced in many countries, and. Luck global responsibility to protect 1 2009 10 21 lyons, donald rothschild, and i. Donald, and lyons, terrence, sovereignty as responsibility. Idealism and realism francis deng dag hammarskjold foundation. Finally, sovereignty remains a necessary component of such national aims and still endows those who. In internal conflicts in africa, sovereign states have often failed to take responsibility for their own citizens welfare and for the humanitarian consequences of conflict, leaving the. Stephen john stedman, negotiation and mediation in internal conflicts, in. Sovereignty as responsibility, responsibility to protect.
From sovereignty as responsibility to the responsibility. Brookings institution press 1996, iciss, report of the international commission on intervention and state sovereignty. The sovereignty of the people was justified on individual rights grounds by 18thcentury revolutionaries and 20thcentury anticolonialists alike. Download pdf africa conflict resolution and international. Identifying africas regional and subregional actors and their mechanisms for handling conflict it is, indeed, the case that the actual number of regional and subregional organisations involved in the management of african conflict may never be known, as there are several ad. Maritime boundaries delimitation and dispute resolution in africa. Deng, sadikiel kimaro, terrence lyons, donald rothchild, i. Conflict in africa the case for thirdparty interventions in conflict. Not if the world recognizes, as these authors argue it should, that sovereignty carries responsibility to fulfill a social contract in which the. The approach used by ecowas and the au in this case was to resolve the conflict using military and diplomatic means and ensure that peace returned and, in tandem, to build democratic institutions. The ideas contained in the report are based on a spectrum of philosophical principles relevant to different actors, from the more general principles of the responsibility to prevent conflict and to rebuild peace, to the more specific threshold criteria and cautionary principles right authority and due process to ensure the ethical. These tragic cases are balanced, happily, by others. Sovereignty, according to the authors, can no longer be seen as a protection against interference, but as a charge of responsibility where the state is.
152 1222 228 1182 1590 1276 804 557 1106 270 705 3 605 339 1487 1256 305 765 1539 276 985 1674 762 893 214 1596 709 1387 819 1355 73 194 477 913 1246 679 511 501 1177 304